Moving African American Students Past Stuck Point

What causes disproportionate numbers of minoritynegatively affect academic progress.
students to become stuck and refrain from taking aStudents believe that they are being unduly
seat at the table of opportunity granted them bydiscriminated against, that impediments to their social
schools? Dr.John Ogbu, noted scholar, after anmobility are posed both at the institutional and structural
extensive survey-based research, shed some light onlevels. They believe that the discrimination they
the working-class, minority, and female youthexperience is undeserved. So they become distrustful
resistance to school (Ogbu, 1991,1994). Ogbu observedof Whites and any establishment with which they are
a notable disparity in the school performance ofassociated . Schools fall under the category of
students belonging to different minority groups. Hedistrusted institutions. Students readily observe cases
noted a distinct relationship between the level ofof biased presentation of textbook material, biased
student performance and the prevailing ideologyassessments, favoritism, tracking, and sometimes open
relating to achievement, also a definite discontinuityracism. Their observations or interpretations of their
between the students' home and school cultures. Heobservations are legion.
claimed that African American youths fail in schoolsUndoubtedly these factors must be taken into
because of deeply historical and pervading societalconsideration when schools make plans and strive
factors. Ogbu referred to this group as involuntaryvigorously to improve the quality of education for
minorities because historically, they had no choice inminority students. Nor will the problems disappear on
their minority and subjugated status. He reasoned thattheir own unless and until these issues are addressed
the way involuntary youths understand their place inhead on. The answers to the problems are not far
the American social order dashes their hopes offrom where the problems themselves reside. Hence,
advancement and opportunity.educators need to analyze each phase of the
When African American youths observe theproblem, fix it, and then move on.
inequitable distribution of social rewards in society-Larabee, D. Public goods, private goods: the American
inferior housing,inferior education, limited and low levelstruggle over educational goals. American Educational
jobs- they are unlikely to work hard. Students echoResearch Journal. Spring 1997, vol. 34, No. 1, pp. 39-81
high sounding dreams of what they would like toOgbu, J.U. (1978). Minority Education and Caste. New
aspire. Nonetheless, their behavior is frequentlyYork:Academic Press.
inconsistent with the accomplishment of these goals.Ogbu, J. U. (1991). Low school performances as an
This disparity between verbalized values and theiradaptation: The case of Blacks in Stockton, California.
actions is most telling. They have superficially, but onlyIn M. Gibson & J. Ogbu (Eds.), Minority status and
superficially bought into the dominant theory of how toschooling: A comparative study of immigrant and
make it in America. They know what the theory is.involuntary minorities (pp. 249-286). New York: Garland.
They have heard the rhetoric. But they do not believeOgbu, J. U. (1994). Racial stratification and education in
it. This "attitude achievement paradox" expresses itselfthe United States: Why inequity persists. Teachers
in subsequent behaviors, dispositions, and identity whichCollege Record, 96, 264-299.